Elmore 'Ewes for the Future' study over five years - Final Report

     

    How do sheep types compare for prime lamb and for wool production? The Elmore Field Days study ‘ Ewes for the Future, fertility, lambs & wool’, has published its final report that will help sheep producers determine the merits of a number of ewe breed alternatives for prime lamb and wool production.

     

    Key Points

    • The Elmore Field Days study ‘Ewes for the Future: fertility, lambs & wool’ compared six breeds of ewes for their lifetime production of meat and wool, from 2014 to 2019.
    • The main characters compared were lambing percentages, lamb growth and wool production.
    • The six breed-types were each represented by 42 ewes. Each breed type group was randomly selected from three properties, with 14 ewe lambs per property after an allowance for culling.
    • The final results indicate large differences in gross meat and wool returns between ewe types.
    • The results are most relevant in the mixed sheep and cropping areas on northern Victoria and southern New South Wales. Elmore is a healthy environment for merino sheep with few worm and feet problems.

    In the study six breed types of ewes were joined to terminal sires, either White Suffolk or Poll Dorset for five years; their first joining was as ewe lambs. The ewe breed types were:

    • Border Leicester x Merino cross ewes. The most common prime lamb mother in the Elmore and northern districts.
    • Multimeat x Merino cross ewes. These ewes carry the Booroola gene for higher lambing percentages. Multimeat breeders claim these ewes consistently rear 30% more lambs than normal crossbreds.
    • Cashmore-Oaklea Performance Maternals (Composites). They have achieved a reputation for good lambing percentages that are assisted by the hybrid vigour between the various breeds.
    • Merino Loddon Valley, locally bred Merinos sourced from Loddon Valley Merino ram breeders. The second most common prime lamb mother in the Elmore and northern districts.
    • Leahcim Merinos, a South Australian Merino stud that has a long history of selecting for a specialty dual purpose merino with low wrinkle and high quality wool.
    • Centre Plus Merino is a group breeding scheme and Merino stud in Central West NSW that aims to produce multipurpose sheep.

    Results

    The ewes were run together as one mob except at lambing. The results presented in the tables only cover the four adult years. The first year joining as ewe lambs occurred only seven weeks after their arrival on the Elmore Field Days farm and their body weights and age were the main reasons for the breed differences. Lambing percentages, lamb growth, and wool are all highly relevant to improving profitability, but no single ewe type exceled in all compartments.

    Prime lambs from the specialist dual purpose merinoewes - Leahcim and Centre Plus; reached the same market weight as lambs from the Border Leicester x Merino ewes on the date of the first lamb sale.  They were also only 1.6 kg lighter than the lambs from the Composite ewes.

    The three Merino types had the greatest wool returns whereas the crossbreds had the greatest lamb returns, see table. When wool and meat were combined, the differences between the crossbreds and merinos were, on average, quite close.  However, average returns of merinos or crossbreds per ewe are a gross simplification; there are differences within the two types.  Feed intake differences must also be taken into account as higher numbers of lambs reared and heavier ewes need more feed. However indications are that dual purpose Merinos with good wool, reproduction and lamb growth are likely to be the most profitable alternative in this Elmore environment. Northern Victoria is highly suited to merino sheep; there were no worm or feet problems at Elmore; the results may be different in wetter climates more suited to cross bred types.  Whole flock systems analyses using models such as GrassGro are needed to fully investigate whole farm profitability.

    Most sheep in Australia are seasonal breeders. They join more readily in the autumn that late spring to early summer. The breeds in this trial differ in their seasonality of breeding. Border Leicester x Merino (BL x M ) cross ewes are well known to be more seasonal breeders than merinos.  The Cashmore – Oaklea Performance Maternals would also be expected to be more seasonal breeders due to their background that includes Border Leicesters, Coopworths and Romneys.

    This study was not designed to compare the seasonality of breeding season between the ewe groups.  Lambing percentages are influenced by many factors including ewe condition score, live weight, nutrition around joining time, nutrition 4 to 6 months before joining as well as the seasonality of the breeding season. 

     

    The full report is available here - download

     

    This project was funded and conducted by the Elmore Field Days Inc. together with The Campaspe Prime Lamb Producers Group with professional help from three organisations and six product support sponsors.

     

     

    Main results; average 4 years as adults, from 2015 to 2019.

    Breed group
    BL x Merino
    Multimeat x Merino
    Cashmore-Oaklea
    Merino, Loddon V
    Leahcim Merino
    Centre Plus M
    Ewe weight at joining (kg)

    74.0

    69.6

    80.2

    58.6

    62.9

    64.7

    Condition score at joining

    3.8

    3.7

    3.9

    3.1

    3.2

    3.5

    Clean fleece weight (kg)

    4.01

    3.13

    2.65

    4.17

    3.99

    3.85

    Fibre diameter mean (um)

    28.7

    26.4

    33.5

    19.6

    20.2

    18.1

    Foetuses scanned per ewe joined

    158%

    262%

    166%

    132%

    110%

    151%

    Lambs born per ewe joined

    151%

    195%

    136%

    118%

    98%

    138%

    Lambs marked per ewe joined

    131%

    146%

    123%

    108%

    88%

    116%

    Lamb weight in spring, before any sales (kg)

    47.5

    45.0

    49.2

    44.3

    47.7

    47.5

     

    Returns per ewe from lamb and wool production with the average DSE estimate per ewe-lambs unit; average 4 years as adults, from 2015 to 2019.

    Breed group
    BL x Merino
    Multimeat x Merino
    Cashmore-Oaklea
    Merino, Loddon V
    Leahcim Merino
    Centre Plus M
    Lamb price, $/head

    $154.19

    $145.57

    $160.87

    $141.49

    $153.47

    $153.24

    Lamb returns, $/ewe
    Lambing percent included in returns

    $196.29

    $203.97

    $190.96

    $149.27

    $130.24

    $175.02

    Wool returns, $/ewe

    $32.59

    $34.76

    $10.46

    $72.99

    $68.30

    $74.02

    Total returns, $/ewe

    $228.88

    $238.72

    $201.42

    $222.26

    $198.53

    $249.05

    DSE rating per ewe-lambs unit

    3.01

    2.98

    3.05

    2.26

    2.20

    2.56

    Returns per DSE, $/DSE
    * expenses not included

    $76.02

    $80.08

    $66.11

    $98.33

    $90.43

    $97.26

     

    The wool and lamb returns per ewe were calculated each year using average prices over the previous 12 months. Lamb returns per ewe were calculated from lambing percentage, lamb live weight, dressing percentage and skin value. Wool returns reflected clean fleece weight and fibre diameter differences.

    Follow Us

    NSW Stud Merino Breeders Association Ltd
    NSW Stud Merino Breeders Association Ltd"Enhancing the value of the Merino"office@merinonsw.com.au
    Locked Bag 4317
    Sydney Olympic Park NSW 2127
    Tel: 02 9763 2744
    Fax: 02 9763 1878

    NSW Stud Merino Breeders Association Trust

    @merinonsw